Eoin Colfer’s bestselling middle-grade adventure mystery novels chronicle the lives of twelve-year-old Artemis Fowl. In the first Artemis Fowl novel, we meet our eponymous character, who is more devious and clever than most adults. The novel follows Fowl after he attempts to catch a fairy in order to obtain gold for ransom. His main motive for this is that the fairy gold will be able to restore the fortune of his esteemed family after the disappearance of his father. Artemis successfully manages to capture a fairy, but he is sorely challenged when the fairy launches an attack on Artemis, his friends and his own family house. The fairy deploys an army of goblins, trolls and other fairies to conduct a major siege.
To preface, I will say that I did not enjoy this novel. I feel as though I, as an adolescent reader, have completely moved past the demographic that this novel was intended for. The characters in the novel were few, and there was rarely any development, which is a necessary component of all storytelling, no matter what your intended reading audience actually is.
Artemis is a thoroughly dislikable protagonist–he can be mean, hedonistic and rarely displays any virtues that other protagonists from children’s books seem to have. I understand that no hero is perfect, but by failing to discuss or reveal why this is, the titular character of this novel falls completely flat on his face. I also felt no attachment to any of the other characters in the novel, as I felt they were too shallow and not developed enough over the 277 pages.
Another problem that I had with the novel was its inclusion of fairy characters. The problem I had with this was that the fairy world–which lives under ours–was too different from the real world to be believable. It made no sense that there were fairies and other magical creatures in a seemingly normal story, and while novel such as Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments is able to develop an interesting and intriguing contrast between these two worlds, Colfer fails once again.
Overall, this novel was a weak start to the story. I expected adventure, jokes and heart, but I was sorely disappointed. This novel, in my opinion, is better suited for children in primary school, and readers who are older and more prolific in their literary skills will find Eoin Colfer’s novel a bore.
GHOST BIRD follows the tale of Aboriginal twins Laney and Stacey, who grew up in their lower-middle-class rural Australian town. Their idyllic life, however, is thrown for a curveball when Laney mysteriously goes missing after going out with her friends. Through a bizarre series of premonitions that fringe on the supernatural, Stacey becomes obsessed with …
Astrid Sholte’s novel combines urban fantasy and murder mystery in a setting that echoes the popular dystopian-style factions of young adult fiction, but with enough unique elements to make it stand out. The world of Four Dead Queens is reminiscent of fantasy, but instead of magic, there is strange and interesting technology that serves as …
Bram Stoker’s Dracula, which has been deemed by both critics and the general public as a staple in both horror and gothic literature, readers are introduced to Jonathan Harker, who travels to the region of Transylvania to meet with Count Dracula in order to assist him in his real estate affairs. It is not long, …
Marcus Zusak’s captivating debut novel follows the story of Liesel, who witnesses the death of her younger brother while on a train through Germany. When she discovers a novel hidden in the snow while standing by her brother’s grave, Liesel pockets it, despite the fact that she has not acquired the ability to read. When …
Jakob Wegelius’ middle-grade novel The Murderer’s Ape tells the story of Sally Jones, an anthropomorphic gorilla working closely with a man known as ‘The Chief.’ Together, the two journey all around the coastlines and rivers of Europe and its surrounding areas aboard a grand sailing ship known as the Hudson Queen. When a midnight expedition …
The absolutely electrifying Australian crime novel ‘The Tell’ by Martin Chatterton weaves a wickedly satisfying tale of Raze Tanic, an upper-class Sydney student whose family-run an illustrious crime ring in the heart of the Australian city. Raze has everything he could ever want, except the relationship with his father, who has been jailed in a …
Book Review – Artemis Fowl by Eoin Colfer
To preface, I will say that I did not enjoy this novel. I feel as though I, as an adolescent reader, have completely moved past the demographic that this novel was intended for. The characters in the novel were few, and there was rarely any development, which is a necessary component of all storytelling, no matter what your intended reading audience actually is.
Artemis is a thoroughly dislikable protagonist–he can be mean, hedonistic and rarely displays any virtues that other protagonists from children’s books seem to have. I understand that no hero is perfect, but by failing to discuss or reveal why this is, the titular character of this novel falls completely flat on his face. I also felt no attachment to any of the other characters in the novel, as I felt they were too shallow and not developed enough over the 277 pages.
Another problem that I had with the novel was its inclusion of fairy characters. The problem I had with this was that the fairy world–which lives under ours–was too different from the real world to be believable. It made no sense that there were fairies and other magical creatures in a seemingly normal story, and while novel such as Cassandra Clare’s The Mortal Instruments is able to develop an interesting and intriguing contrast between these two worlds, Colfer fails once again.
Overall, this novel was a weak start to the story. I expected adventure, jokes and heart, but I was sorely disappointed. This novel, in my opinion, is better suited for children in primary school, and readers who are older and more prolific in their literary skills will find Eoin Colfer’s novel a bore.
RATING:
Plot: 5/10
Characters: 3.5/10
Writing: 6/10
OVERALL: 5.5/10
Related Posts
Book Review – Ghost Bird by Lisa Fuller
GHOST BIRD follows the tale of Aboriginal twins Laney and Stacey, who grew up in their lower-middle-class rural Australian town. Their idyllic life, however, is thrown for a curveball when Laney mysteriously goes missing after going out with her friends. Through a bizarre series of premonitions that fringe on the supernatural, Stacey becomes obsessed with …
Book Review – Four Dead Queens by Astrid Scholte
Astrid Sholte’s novel combines urban fantasy and murder mystery in a setting that echoes the popular dystopian-style factions of young adult fiction, but with enough unique elements to make it stand out. The world of Four Dead Queens is reminiscent of fantasy, but instead of magic, there is strange and interesting technology that serves as …
Book Review – Dracula by Bram Stoker
Bram Stoker’s Dracula, which has been deemed by both critics and the general public as a staple in both horror and gothic literature, readers are introduced to Jonathan Harker, who travels to the region of Transylvania to meet with Count Dracula in order to assist him in his real estate affairs. It is not long, …
Book Review – The Book Thief by Marcus Zusak
Marcus Zusak’s captivating debut novel follows the story of Liesel, who witnesses the death of her younger brother while on a train through Germany. When she discovers a novel hidden in the snow while standing by her brother’s grave, Liesel pockets it, despite the fact that she has not acquired the ability to read. When …
Book Review – The Murderer’s Ape by Jakob Wegelius
Jakob Wegelius’ middle-grade novel The Murderer’s Ape tells the story of Sally Jones, an anthropomorphic gorilla working closely with a man known as ‘The Chief.’ Together, the two journey all around the coastlines and rivers of Europe and its surrounding areas aboard a grand sailing ship known as the Hudson Queen. When a midnight expedition …
Book Review – The Tell by Martin Chatterton
The absolutely electrifying Australian crime novel ‘The Tell’ by Martin Chatterton weaves a wickedly satisfying tale of Raze Tanic, an upper-class Sydney student whose family-run an illustrious crime ring in the heart of the Australian city. Raze has everything he could ever want, except the relationship with his father, who has been jailed in a …