In the final novel from the Magisterium series by Cassandra Clare and Holly Black, Callum Hunt is faced with the task of destroying Alex Strike and the chaos that followed in the wake of the events of the penultimate novel The Silver Mask. Callum Hunt is now entering his Gold Year, the final year of his magical training at the Magisterium. With Aaron now closer to Callum than ever before, Callum and his friends take on the challenge on scavenging for elementals that will finally be able to bring Alex down from his heights as a Makar and wielder of chaos magic. With the stakes being higher than ever, Callum has to band together with friends old and new to save the magical world as he knows it from indefinite destruction.
This was an extremely bittersweet novel for me for a few reasons: I was sad to see the series come to an end, but also felt the novel hitting the same positive notes that the previous two had set. This novel, rightly so, lacked a lot of the playful and innocent fun that the first two novels seemed to have, and I felt as though without this added humour and heart, the series finale lost its footing quite a bit. However, this did not stop me from hanging on to each chapter as it came, but I feel as though the novel went in a direction that was not owing to the pace and structure set by the former four books.
As well as this, I lost all respect for Alex Strike in this novel. I had a very tenuous relationship with this good-turned-bad facade delivered by Alex, and this novel only painted him in a worse light. In this book, Alex almost seemed like an idiot, and a lot more dislikeable than any novel’s villain should be. Throughout the novels, we have been lead to believe that no-one should be overlooked for the role of villain–we have gone from Alastair to Rufus, from Anastasia to Call himself, but Alex has, by far, been my least favourite of all. Without a solid villain, any battle between good and evil will completely fall flat. I’m sorry to say this, but Magisterium certainly lacked depth in response to its weak villainous delivery. The ending was also rather rushed, and–at only 239 pages–there was no reason to hurry with the delivery. I understand that there may have been some time constraints or other problems affecting the course of the novel, but in order to have a proper send-off for a series’s final book, ending it well is CRUCIAL. The Golden Tower fell flat in this regard, too.
Even though this part of the series may have fallen a little flat in its resolutions, I have no problem with saying that I truly enjoyed reading it. I loved Callum, I was intrigued by the magical interworking systems, and I thought that the dialogue was a perfect blend of humorous and enthralling. The Golden Tower certainly does not round out the series perfectly, but the stellar performances from The Silver Mask and The Bronze Key leaves a positive place in middle-grade magical fiction.
In the first book of a fantastic new middle-grade series ‘Tilly and the Boookwanderers‘ we follow Matilda ‘Tilly’ Pages, an eleven-year-old book lover who is cared for by her loving grandfather and grandmother in the five-storey London bookshop Pages & Co. Tilly has lived with her grandparents for as long as she could remember, since …
Scythe is a dystopian young adult novel by Neal Shusterman, and it tells the tale of a futuristic society in which all forms of death have been eradicated, and the only way a human can die is by being ‘gleaned’, a word which is synonymous with murder. However, only a few selection of trained individuals–known …
The trials and tribulations of an English upper class noble are thrown into increasingly dangerous–but equally hilarious–lengths in American author Mackenzi Lee’s novel ‘The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue’. The story centres around Lord Henry Montague as his affluent father sends him away on a Grand Tour throughout Europe with his sister and close …
Melina Marchetta’s coming-of-age novel is a refreshingly mature young adult adventure that captures the feeling on the crux of growing up and watching all that was familiar with the world shift into something new. On the Jellicoe Road transports the reader to a world caught between the dreams of childhood and the horrors of reality, …
In 1984, one of modern literature’s most celebrated works, readers are introduced to Winston Smith, who lives in a dystopian society in which everything–from actions, movements, careers, and, even in some cases, thoughts–are monitored and recorded tirelessly. In this society, all individuals are governed by organisations who mandate conformity and allegiance, and who will cause …
M.T Anderson’s enthralling storytelling and Andrea Offermann’s evocative illustrations transport the reader to the age of the Knights of the Round Table in this rich graphic novel. The narrative follows the formula of an epic tale, following a hero’s journey and his many conquests as he fights to retain his honour and regain his love. …
Book Review – The Golden Tower by Cassandra Clare and Holly Black
This was an extremely bittersweet novel for me for a few reasons: I was sad to see the series come to an end, but also felt the novel hitting the same positive notes that the previous two had set. This novel, rightly so, lacked a lot of the playful and innocent fun that the first two novels seemed to have, and I felt as though without this added humour and heart, the series finale lost its footing quite a bit. However, this did not stop me from hanging on to each chapter as it came, but I feel as though the novel went in a direction that was not owing to the pace and structure set by the former four books.
As well as this, I lost all respect for Alex Strike in this novel. I had a very tenuous relationship with this good-turned-bad facade delivered by Alex, and this novel only painted him in a worse light. In this book, Alex almost seemed like an idiot, and a lot more dislikeable than any novel’s villain should be. Throughout the novels, we have been lead to believe that no-one should be overlooked for the role of villain–we have gone from Alastair to Rufus, from Anastasia to Call himself, but Alex has, by far, been my least favourite of all. Without a solid villain, any battle between good and evil will completely fall flat. I’m sorry to say this, but Magisterium certainly lacked depth in response to its weak villainous delivery. The ending was also rather rushed, and–at only 239 pages–there was no reason to hurry with the delivery. I understand that there may have been some time constraints or other problems affecting the course of the novel, but in order to have a proper send-off for a series’s final book, ending it well is CRUCIAL. The Golden Tower fell flat in this regard, too.
Even though this part of the series may have fallen a little flat in its resolutions, I have no problem with saying that I truly enjoyed reading it. I loved Callum, I was intrigued by the magical interworking systems, and I thought that the dialogue was a perfect blend of humorous and enthralling. The Golden Tower certainly does not round out the series perfectly, but the stellar performances from The Silver Mask and The Bronze Key leaves a positive place in middle-grade magical fiction.
RATINGS
Characters: 9/10
Plot: 9/10
Writing: 8/10
Overall: 8/10
Related Posts
Book Review – Tilly and the Bookwanderers by Anna James
In the first book of a fantastic new middle-grade series ‘Tilly and the Boookwanderers‘ we follow Matilda ‘Tilly’ Pages, an eleven-year-old book lover who is cared for by her loving grandfather and grandmother in the five-storey London bookshop Pages & Co. Tilly has lived with her grandparents for as long as she could remember, since …
Book Review – Scythe by Neal Shusterman
Scythe is a dystopian young adult novel by Neal Shusterman, and it tells the tale of a futuristic society in which all forms of death have been eradicated, and the only way a human can die is by being ‘gleaned’, a word which is synonymous with murder. However, only a few selection of trained individuals–known …
Book Review – The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue by Mackenzi Lee
The trials and tribulations of an English upper class noble are thrown into increasingly dangerous–but equally hilarious–lengths in American author Mackenzi Lee’s novel ‘The Gentleman’s Guide to Vice and Virtue’. The story centres around Lord Henry Montague as his affluent father sends him away on a Grand Tour throughout Europe with his sister and close …
Book Review – On the Jellicoe Road by Melina Marchetta
Melina Marchetta’s coming-of-age novel is a refreshingly mature young adult adventure that captures the feeling on the crux of growing up and watching all that was familiar with the world shift into something new. On the Jellicoe Road transports the reader to a world caught between the dreams of childhood and the horrors of reality, …
Book Review – 1984 by George Orwell
In 1984, one of modern literature’s most celebrated works, readers are introduced to Winston Smith, who lives in a dystopian society in which everything–from actions, movements, careers, and, even in some cases, thoughts–are monitored and recorded tirelessly. In this society, all individuals are governed by organisations who mandate conformity and allegiance, and who will cause …
Book Review – Yvain, The Knight of the Lion
M.T Anderson’s enthralling storytelling and Andrea Offermann’s evocative illustrations transport the reader to the age of the Knights of the Round Table in this rich graphic novel. The narrative follows the formula of an epic tale, following a hero’s journey and his many conquests as he fights to retain his honour and regain his love. …